Oct 152017

Check out this Cinnamon Toast Crunch Milkshake.  I made a Fruity Pebbles milkshake not long ago and it got me thinking about what other kinds of cereal milkshakes I could make. We always have Cinnamon Toast Crunch on hand because it’s my youngest son’s favorite cereal, so I wanted to try making a Cinnamon Toast Crunch Milkshake. I was really happy with the way it came out and a big part of that was the ice cream I used. I decided to use a non-traditional flavor and I am so glad that I did.

Cinnamon Toast Crunch Milkshake

This delicious Cinnamon Toast Crunch Milkshake will rock your world! Only 3 ingredients are needed and your milkshake is ready in minutes!

Here’s what you need:

  • 4 large scoops of Turkey Hill Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream
  • 1 cup of crushed cinnamon toast crunch cereal
  • 1 ½ cups of milk

Here’s what you do:

1. Start by crushing up your Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal.  I crushed mine in a bowl, but my husband crushes his in a Ziploc bag.  Either way is fine. I crushed mine up pretty fine, but it is going to end up in the blender, so don’t kill yourself crushing it up into super small pieces like I did.

This delicious Cinnamon Toast Crunch Milkshake will rock your world! Only 3 ingredients are needed and your milkshake is ready in minutes!
2. Then add all of your ingredients into a blender and blend it until it’s smooth.

This delicious Cinnamon Toast Crunch Milkshake will rock your world! Only 3 ingredients are needed and your milkshake is ready in minutes!

3. I served my milkshakes in a cup with a crushed Cinnamon Toast Crunch rim because I am fancy like that. You don’t have to go through the trouble if you want instant gratification and need to drink your milkshake immediately.  But if you want to  be fancy, too, go for it – it only takes an extra minute to do it and it sure does look cool.

This delicious Cinnamon Toast Crunch Milkshake will rock your world! Only 3 ingredients are needed and your milkshake is ready in minutes!I am really happy with this Cinnamon Toast Crunch Milkshake. I tried it with vanilla ice cream at first, but the pumpkin ice cream that I used the second time around made it so much better.  Plus it’s perfect for the fall!

  59 Responses to “Out of This World Cinnamon Toast Crunch Milkshake”

  1. Wow…..this is so beautiful

  2. Oh wow. I have never made a milk shake other than the traditional way. I guess it is time to try these new variations to the recipe. I think your cinnamon toast crunch milkshake recipe is fantastic! Thanks for the idea.

  3. Holy to the moly! I love Cinnamon Toast Crunch, and I love milkshakes. This is perfect for me! Om nom nom.

  4. We usually have a box (or two!) lying around haha, I am definitely going to test this out. Not to mention, that ice cream sounds perfect!

  5. This looks so good! I loved this cereal as a a kid, and would so drink this shake now as an adult! I bet my daughter would have fun making this with me one night too. She would think it is such a fun treat!

  6. This is my husband’s favorite cereal, and we’re both addicted to milkshakes, so I’m going to be blaming you when our diets go horribly wrong. 🙂

  7. Yum! I need to try this out. I’d use the pumpkin ice cream too! I love pumpkin stuff. I know Burger King released one of these, but yours looks so much better.

  8. Oh wow this looks absolutely delicious, my other half has a thing for cinnamon as well so he would love this as well I think.

  9. Whoa! What a decadent milkshake treat! I’m a huge cinnamon fan so this looks amazing!

  10. Well now I just have to go find me some pumpkin pie ice cream. This looks to die for delicious.

  11. Cinnamon Toast Crunch is my all time favorite cereal! I’ve loved it ever since I was a kid. This milkshake sounds amazing! The next time I buy a box, I’m making this!

  12. We always have Cinnamon Toast Crunch because Stella loves it. I think I’m going to have to try your shakes, they sound so good.

  13. My two favorite things in one cup? I’m in heaven! I’ll have to try this out one of these days, but without my son and boyfriend around. I don’t like to share lol

  14. Oh my goodness that looks so good! I wish I could drink it right off the page. This weekend I’m going to be alone with my kiddo and I think we are going to do stuff like this because it’s just fun.

  15. This looks simply amazing. My husband loves cinnamon toast crunch. I’ll have to make this for him.

  16. Umm, this does not help with my diet one little bit. This looks so darn good I am literally drooling!

  17. This is basically heaven on earth for me! Cinnamon Toast Crunch is my favorite cereal and such a delicious treat is just too tasty not to try.

  18. So fun — I love the pumpkin and cinnamon flavor combo, especially in the fall, and the presentation looks great!

  19. Definitely out of this world kind of milkshake, I am loving it thought never tried a cinnamon flavoured milkshake before

  20. Cinnamon Toast Crunch is a great tasting cereal and in a milkshake sounds like it would be even better. This is a treat my kids would love too.

  21. This sounds amazing! I have seen so many recipes for awesome looking milkshakes lately.

  22. I could definitely go for those flavors! Yum! The pumpkin pie ice cream must be so good with the cinnamon flavor!

  23. This sounds so good! I have some Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal right now so I’ll have to try this!

  24. That is absolutely one of my most favorite cereals! I think it’s awesome to turn it into a milkshake, I’m sure the flavor is amazing!

  25. My husband and kids love the taste of this cereal. I bet they would go CRAZY for this milkshake. Gotta try it.

  26. You need to STOP the insanity of this shake! I want this in my mouth NOW!

  27. This looks so incredible! I am very pregnant right now and craving anything sweet. I have to make one of these! How delicious!

  28. This looks so good and refreshing! I can’t wait to make it because I’m currently in love with everything that has to do with pumpkin and cinnamon! I’m sure the kids will love it too.

  29. Wow this is definitely out of this world! I want one right now, my mouth is watering!

  30. Oh good grief this milkshake looks FANTASTIC! Out of this world definitely is a great description, and easy too! Love that!

  31. I am no longer shocked by how innovative food is becoming. This looks extremely interesting. I think I will try it 🙂

  32. The cereal itself is plenty. This is simply an awesome, over-the-top treat the kids will love!

  33. Oh goodness. How delicious can that be! I am glad to have come across this recipe. I’ve been craving for a good milk shake and now here it is! I wish it was not this late at night. Oh well, I will make this tomorrow!

  34. Yes to recipes like this during the Fall! I just love that there’s a pumpkin flavored ice cream that we can use for this recipe! Makes the job easier!

  35. That’s something that the kids would love especially since it’s a milkshake and they’re huge fans of milkshakes. I think the cinnamon toast crunch cereal adds a lovely flavor!!!

  36. What?What?What? Oh yes, this does look amazing, delicious and awesome. I don’t think I’ve ever tried pumpkin ice cream, but I’m going to look for a pint at the grocery store and whip one of these bad boys up!

  37. What the heck! We love Cinnamon Toast Crunch and would totally try this milkshake!

  38. I love anything with cinnamon, so this milkshake is surely delicious!

  39. What an awesome idea! I will have to make this for my kids this weekend. It looks so delicious! I tried your fruity pebble milkshake before and it was a hit with the kids. I know this would be too.

  40. I love cinnamon, the flavour goes so well with almost everything. This milkshake looks really promising. Will try this out over the weekend.

  41. My ids love when I made FUN and creative milkshakes as well. Where were all these Delicious concoctions when we were kiddos?

  42. OMG! this looks fab! I wish I could have dairy because cinnamon toast crunch is the best and was my favorite growing up!

  43. We love creating extreme shakes. My son loves Cinnamon Toast Crunch so we have to try this version. They are so delicious but I feel myself gain weight just looking at it!

  44. You know I want to try this right? This is such a sweet and amazing treat for me and the kids!

  45. Guess I am heading to the supermarket tomorrow because I need to try this. Love it

  46. Pumpkin ice cream is not something I have seen around here. It sounds good. I will have to look for it.

  47. cinnamon toast crunch is my favorite cereal of them all. I need to give this milkshake a try ASAP!

  48. This is absolutely everything!!! Looks so yummy .. and I love cinnamon toast crunch too!

  49. I was surprised to see the pumpkin ice cream in there! Love pumpkin. This sounds like an awesome and fun recipe.


  50. Yum! This sounds like a great milkshake. I could definitely go for one of those right now.

  51. My husband would absolutely love this. He loves pumpkin anything! I’d have to use vanilla ice cream…not a fan of pumpkin anything.

  52. I bet this tastes absolutely amazing! My husband has always liked Cinnamon Toast Crunch, so I now he would flip over this milkshake.

  53. Great idea to use pumpkin ice cream. The combo of the pumpkin flavors with the cinnamon toast crunch are perfection.

  54. Cereal milkshakes are seriously so awesome! I have never made one like this but have used the more fruity cereals before.

  55. Cinnamon Toast Crunch was (and still is) my favorite cereal growing up! I was in NYC recently and had a Fruity Pebbles Milkshake and it was phenomenal! I will definitely be making this asap!

  56. Oh hell naw! Girl, i am thinking my teeth will hurt me??? Eeekkk… Sounds yummy and looks GOOD. But it still hurts LOL. Did you enjoy? I’m sure you did LOL.

  57. I have to make this for my son, who loves cinnamon anything and milkshakes. Thanks for this, you probably made his weekend. Blessings!

  58. OMG! This looks absolutely delicious and decadent. I think I would get myself in trouble if I made this here at home. We would all just love this.

  59. This does sound out of this world! Cinnamon Toast Crunch is a favorite cereal at our house so I’m sure this milkshake would be pretty popular too!